Tono:
Introducción:
G
When I was with you I was real
G
When I was with you I could be myself
G
When I was with you I didn't feel
Bm Am Em
Lost, confused or frightened
C G F
Or scared to be who I am
E A G C G C G
When I was with you I was real
G A# C
We both think you look great in a head sweater
G C
We both enjoy an empty cafe
G A# C
We both are actual human beings to waiters
G C G
We both are not totally straight
C G
None of that changes
A# C G
None of that has changed
spoken: Okay?
C G
JASE, spoken: Okay
G A# C
Judith: We both like drinking hot tea in warm weather
G C
We both like playing guitar
G A# C
We both like when you tell me the plots of bad movies
G C G
We both forget our card at the bar almost always
A# C G
When I was with you I was real
A# C G
When I was with you I could be myself
A# C G
When I was with you I was real
Bm Bº Em
Like as real as my retainer
C G F
That I left at your house one time
Em A G
When I am with you I am real
(spoken)
A# C G
Now, do you remember what I said the first time we did the questions? About my perfect day?
D C G
JASE, spoken: Yes. You said that tomorrow could be the perfect day if we let it be.
A# C G
That's not the kind of answer you forget, especially when the person answering it is wearing a low-cut blouse
D C
JUDITH, spoken: You thinking about my blouse?
G A# C
JASE, spoken: I'm remembering it. Do you remember my answer?
G C G
JUDITH, spoken: Hmm&hellip with broad strokes. Picnic in the park with your family. Mini-muffin basket for lunch.
A# C G
Everyone getting together under a big blanket and watching the entire third season of The Office
JASE, spoken: Still true
A# C G
JUDITH, spoken: And I'd still wanna be there with you
(Flipping pages)
G C G
Question 5. "When was the last time you sang to yourself? To someone else?"
JASE, spoken: This afternoon. To Henry
A#
JASE, spoken: He only stayed for half
C G
JUDITH, spoken: The last time I sang was on my way over here in the car
JASE, spoken: You sang?! What did you sing?
A# C G
JUDITH: Oh, I'm gonna die out here
C
JASE, spoken: Oh, that hit. I forgot about that one
G A#
JUDITH, spoken: And I think that counts as me singing to someone else. Ask me the next one
C G
JASE, spoken: Question 6. "If you were able to live to the age of 90 and retain either
C G A#
the mind or body of a 30-year-old for the last 60 years of your life, which would you want?"
C
JUDITH, spoken: Do you remember my answer?
G
JASE, spoken: Body. Do you remember mine?
A# C
JUDITH, spoken: Mind. See? Nothing has changed. We're still a good half-sexy team.
G
Question 7. "Do you have a secret hunch about how you will die?"
A# C
You said that you thought you were gonna die in your car, but you weren't sure how
G
JASE, spoken: Right? And you said that you weren't afraid of death
A#
JUDITH, spoken: And I'm still not. I'm only afraid of dying alone. Read the next one
C
JASE, spoken: Question 8. "Name 3 things you and your partner appear to have in common."
G
JUDITH, spoken: Easy
(Chorus: sung)
A# C G
We both are super good at Settlers of Catan
C
We both become monsters when we lose
G A# C G
We both think we have the best worst name for a band
C
We both check Twitter for our news
(spoken)
G A# C
We both say the other is better at cooking
G C
We both hate that kitchen island we built
G A# C
We both need a glass of water on the bedside table
G D C
We both recycle purely out of guilt
G A# C G
We both have dreams much bigger than ourselves
C
We both think that's how to live
G A# C
We both put up a fight for all the right reasons
G D C
And we both eventually give
G
I tried so hard to separate
A# C
Who you are from who you were
G
But now I'm reevaluating
A# C
How similar you are to her
You have the same voice
Em
And the same cadence when you speak
C
If I close my eyes
D G
You still sound to me like Natalie
A# C G
When I was with you I was real
(Am I in love with Natalie?)
C B
When I was with you I could be myself
(Or who's right in front of me?)
A# C G
Both: When I am with you I can feel
Bm Em
Shivers running down my spine
C G
Your skin close to mine
G Em A G
It's like my 5 senses make my heart defenseless
With you
C G
When I am with you I am real
(with you)
C G
When I am with you I am actually too real
(with you)
C G D
When I am with you everything feels
(with you)
C G
Both: So real.